India's Largest IPO: A Misfortunate Timing

On October 22, Hyundai Motor India Limited made a significant splash in the investment world by listing on the National Stock Exchange of India (NSE). This initial public offering (IPO) raised an astonishing $3.3 billion, marking it as the largest IPO in Indian history and the second largest globally for the year 2024. Despite this incredible achievement, the debut of Hyundai India did not unfold as anticipated, with its stock price slipping nearly 6% from the initial offering price of ₹1960 to ₹1844.6. This drop saw the company’s market capitalization decrease to ₹15.3 trillion, causing a stir in the market as investors turned their attention to the fluctuating economic performance of India.

The first day’s performance of Hyundai India raised eyebrows, particularly due to the divergence in sentiment between institutional and retail investorsWhile institutional interest remained strong, retail investors approached the IPO with caution, posing questions about the long-term profitability and sustainability of Hyundai's market presence in India.

The IPO ceremony took place amid heightened anticipation at the Bombay Stock ExchangeHowever, as the day unfolded, industry analysts began to debate whether the timing was advantageousThe backdrop of India’s fast-evolving economic landscape painted a complex picture of opportunity juxtaposed with instability.

For several years, India’s economy had experienced remarkable growth, reigning as a focal point in the emerging marketsSince 2020, the performance of the Indian stock market had elevated significantly, with the Bombay SENSEX index soaring to heights that eclipsed many developed markets in the WestHowever, by October 2024, signs of fatigue began to surface in the Indian stock market, characterized by a retreat of foreign investors leading to volatilityReports indicated that in October alone, over $10 billion was withdrawn from Indian equity markets as external factors weighed down investor sentiment, such as slowing economic growth, uninspiring corporate earnings, and restrictive monetary policies by the central bank.

The repercussions of these market movements were reflected starkly when, on November 4, the SENSEX plummeted by more than 1000 points, a blow significantly tied to sustained foreign outflows

Advertisements

Analysts at Goldman Sachs noted that the influx of capital towards Chinese markets negatively impacted the liquidity of Indian stocks, particularly those perceived to be overvaluedIn tandem, Bernstein's analysts pointed out that even though India’s capital markets were relatively highly valued within the emerging market landscape, they showed signs of vulnerability in the short term.

These market fluctuations cast a shadow over Hyundai’s IPOThe skepticism amongst retail investors about the projected profitability of Hyundai’s operations intensified the already challenging scenarioThis IPO was intended to solidify Hyundai’s position in emerging markets, particularly targeting the burgeoning electric vehicle (EV) sector as the Indian government offers tax incentives to attract foreign automakers into the electric mobility space.

Hyundai aimed to leverage the IPO funds to enhance their investments in research and development, especially in hybrid and electric vehicle offerings, vying to close the gap with market leader Maruti Suzuki, who has established a robust footprint in the Indian automotive landscapeHowever, it is essential to underline that much of the capital raised was set to return to Hyundai's headquarters, earmarked for international expansion and technological innovation rather than injecting fresh enthusiasm into the domestic market.

Investor confidence was further shaken by Hyundai Motor Group's Q3 2024 financial results which reported a 6.5% decline in operating profit year-on-year to 3.6 trillion won, falling below earlier expectations due to sluggish sales in key markets and electric vehicle segmentsThe overall poor performance of Hyundai's parent company amplified investor hesitation towards Hyundai India’s IPO, as potential investors worried about the implications for long-term profitability in a competitive and challenging market.

From a local market perspective, Hyundai faces significant competition from well-established rivals such as Tata Motors and Maruti Suzuki, who boast advantages in areas including pricing, brand recognition, and product diversity

Advertisements

Tata Motors, with its strong local production capabilities, and Maruti Suzuki, historically dominant in market share, have made penetrating the domestic market notably challenging for Hyundai.

Looking ahead, the immediate outlook for Hyundai India appears daunting, with the current volatility in capital markets and a downturn in domestic automotive sales possibly impacting future performanceReports have indicated that 2024 has witnessed signs of a slow down in the automotive market as the trend of cooling sales began mid-yearMajor players including Tata Motors, Maruti Suzuki, and Hyundai itself reported stagnant or declining sales figures despite ongoing promotional efforts.

While Maruti Suzuki managed to achieve a minimal increase of 3.1% in sales for June 2024, Hyundai's figures stagnated, and Tata Motors saw an 8% decrease in the same monthFactors such as last year’s high base effect, minimal new vehicle launches, and broader economic pressures from inflation have severely curtailed consumer spending in this sector.

Moreover, there appears to be a perception among many retail investors that Hyundai’s fundraising primarily aims at repurchasing equity for its parent company, raising doubts about its commitment to augmenting investments in the Indian marketThis skepticism has undoubtedly dampened the reception of the IPO within the retail investment community.

Despite the short-term challenges and prevailing skepticism, there exists a silver lining regarding Hyundai India’s long-term prospectsReports have indicated that electric vehicles constituted approximately 5% of total automobile sales in India from October 2022 to September 2023. Projections suggest a dramatic increase in the EV segment, potentially capturing over 40% of the Indian automobile market by 2030. This presents a significant market opportunity for Hyundai as it strives to carve out a larger share in the burgeoning electric vehicle space.

Industry analysts maintain that although Hyundai's IPO performance was underwhelming, the ongoing development of India’s economy indicates a prolific future

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements